EricJKopit
Mar 08 2006, 01:48 PM
Anyone throw one yet? How does it compare to a CE TL? More stable?
I'm thinking the Star TL may be a bit too stable, probably flies like a broken in 11x TB?
oakhollowdgc
Mar 08 2006, 03:01 PM
Picked some up at the factory yesterday then hit the practice field.
These things are beautiful. Thrown with a slight hyzer they flip flat and fly. Only a slight fade at the end.
Released straight there is a slight turnover resulting in a predictable S shot.
Grippy like the 1st run CE's. I actually broke out a 1st run CE TL that was thrown only a couple of times and was getting more distance out of the Star TL.
The whole Star line overall should be as good as if not better than the CE line both in my opinion and in that of some Innova employees.
The Star valk is as fast as the CE valk. Much quicker than the Champion version.
Same can be said for the Star TL.
And most importantly at a fraction of the price as CE.
xterramatt
Mar 08 2006, 03:20 PM
I hit a 350 foot ace with one first day I threw it.
Into a Discatcher Traveler. On it's side. Yes it stuck. Yes i was amazed.
EricJKopit
Mar 08 2006, 03:26 PM
What weights did you throw sd? I am definitely interested if it is faster but not necessarily more stable than the 170g CE TL I throw...
oakhollowdgc
Mar 08 2006, 04:33 PM
ooops not Super Dave, rather Rick Black posting with his permission.
I was throwing 3 170 orange Star TL's. 1st run CE TL was a 171.
the_beastmaster
Mar 08 2006, 10:11 PM
For those of who haven't thrown a CE TL (I wish I had $100-150 to do so), can anymore compare the Star TL to the Pro or the CFR?
I've found the CFR to be more overstable than the Pro, and I'm wondering if the Star will be even more overstable or somewhere in the middle. Thanks.
xterramatt
Mar 09 2006, 12:12 AM
From my run ins (few) with the other plastics, I would say the star is in the middle. It's a sweet flyer, threw it tonight, it bombs straight. This disc is a keeper. In the bag. What is coming out? Probably my Nightshift Orc.
davidbihl
Mar 20 2006, 07:34 PM
This is a great disc, got some today, go where you throw kinda disc flat flip flies straight. Nice fairway driver in between a Roc and a faster driver. Kinda reminds me of the leopard but more stable, and a little faster.
AWSmith
Mar 22 2006, 11:11 PM
I picked one up at a tourny the other day (170g). In one throw I decided it was definitly in the bag.
Heres the best way i can describe its flight:
HSS - just like my SE Teebirds (TL mold) but a little more stable
LSS - B/w a Champ Valk and a SE Teebird
It flies as long as my Pro Starfire, a little longer actually. Its become my go to distance disc for everything except L-R cross winds. Its easy to control too. The plastic holds up great I've smacked a few trees pretty **** hard and it still has its shape, perfect. Next tourny I go to I'm gonna pick a couple more.
the_beastmaster
Mar 23 2006, 12:17 AM
Yeah, the Star TL is pretty much the best. I think it flies like a brand new Pro Teebird-L but longer with a little more low speed fade, which is great.
Thrown with hyzer they'll flip up, turn a bit, and fly forever ending up dead straight. The best thing though is in the woods: throw these flat at 70% power and they are the straightest thing ever.
Great disc, best effort so far in Star. Thank you, Innova.
xterramatt
Apr 20 2006, 10:32 PM
I've thrown the Star TL a lot now. It seems to take flutter extremely well. I've thrown it flat and hard, with a little flutter, and it just erases the flutter and it doesn't seem to affect the flight. They just come out, get flat, and glide. I wish I played more golf so I could really use it during rounds. I'll test it out in Augusta this Sunday some more.
I'm getting 95-97% of the distance as with my Wraiths and TeeRexes with it. Not bad for a sleeper disc... with a speed rating of 7.
I've thrown the Star TL a lot now. It seems to take flutter extremely well. I've thrown it flat and hard, with a little flutter, and it just erases the flutter and it doesn't seem to affect the flight. They just come out, get flat, and glide. I wish I played more golf so I could really use it during rounds. I'll test it out in Augusta this Sunday some more.
I'm getting 95-97% of the distance as with my Wraiths and TeeRexes with it. Not bad for a sleeper disc... with a speed rating of 7.
What he said.
mikeP
May 28 2006, 07:23 PM
I just picked up one of these last week and it flies great. I don't throw much pro/dx plastic and I have always been looking for a driver in a better plastic without the low speed fade that usually comes with it. This is that disc. You can throw it with a touch of hyzer and it flips up and flies straight with minimal fade at the end. Mine is a pale yellow 175g. Now I can feel better about my Star TB being so friggin overstable because alongside the TL they are the perfect pair for stable fairway drives in all conditions. I played today in like 93 degrees and it was soooo grippy. Be careful however when buying max weight...at the store I got it at they had a scale and the 3 other TLs marked 175g weighed 177g and 178g.
quickdisc
May 28 2006, 07:32 PM
:DI have one at 181 grams.
mikeP
May 28 2006, 08:35 PM
:DI have one at 181 grams.
Was that a factory second or did they actually write "175g" on the back? Disc companies should not encourage the use of illegal discs by mismarking overweight discs. 176g is one thing, but 181g... :eek:
AviarX
May 28 2006, 09:45 PM
i don't think they weigh every single disc do they ... :confused:
i just started throwing TL's and i have a question about them for you who do. do they tend to go far even thrown low? (i was under the impression slower discs needed more heighth to go far, but my TL seems to almost rise on its own when thrown hard and low. also, do the STAR versions have a little more low speed fade? that's my experience but i was given two Champion TL's and each were already broken in...
xterramatt
May 28 2006, 11:11 PM
I don't think it will fly as low as a Wraith for the whole flight. To me it seems to have more lift than most discs, like a Leopard, it'll go and go, but not particularly low. It's a disc that doesn't really mind height. Whereas the faster drivers seem to stall out if they get air, the TL and Leopard seem to defy logic.
dannyreeves
May 29 2006, 03:35 PM
The TL is slower than most of the super-fast drivers out now but I wouldn't call it slow. It is still pretty fast.
mikeP
May 29 2006, 08:16 PM
i don't think they weigh every single disc do they ... :confused:
Discs in the same run do not vary much in weight, only 1-2 grams in my experience. So for example if one orange TL weighs 179g, then the whole darn run is significantly overweight. I understand that new plastics require some tweaking to get right and the disc companies do not want to just throw money away when a whole run is overweight, but they could at least sell them as X-outs for people not planning to use them in tournaments rather than abusing the trust that the PDGA extends to them with the proverbial "PDGA APPROVED" stamp.
About the TL's flight, it does have that almost convex bottow wing like the Wraith/TeeRex/Starfire L/Beast/Leopard that seems to provide an almost magical lift/glide to the discs flight. This allows for a lower profile flight I believe. Also, given its slightly understable tendencies it can be thrown low with a touch of hyzer, giving it even more lift. I love to do the same thing with my Star Wraith, getting 400'+ in a straight line very low to the ground. As pointed out in the previous post, the real magic of the TL is its ability to fly high without the punishing low speed fade of most other drivers in its class. I've had people criticize my drive with the TL right out of my hand as too high, only to watch amazed as it finishes by dropping straight out of the air.
eddie_ogburn
May 30 2006, 09:59 AM
The star TL is my new favorite disc. I can throw it hard and flat and it will stay straight with a little fade at the end. Thanks Innova!
jaxx
May 30 2006, 02:35 PM
yeah how many birdies did u get this past weekend with that TL, i know u got hole 2 sunnyside both rounds
quickdisc
May 30 2006, 04:41 PM
Is your TL stable or slightly understable ?
eddie_ogburn
May 30 2006, 05:55 PM
yeah how many birdies did u get this past weekend with that TL, i know u got hole 2 sunnyside both rounds
Haha... yeah I got quite a few with it. Its the perfect disc for 4 on the darkside too.
Is your TL stable or slightly understable ?
My TL is stable. I have to throw it with anny to make it turn. If I release it hard and flat, its going exactly where I release it dead straight for about 350ft and finishes slightly left.
20460chase
May 30 2006, 06:21 PM
I have a red one beefy enough for me to take the Teebird outta my bag. Ive tried beating the crap outta this thing by putting it in a towel and beating a cement floor. Doesnt matter. Still Beefy.
DSproAVIAR
Jun 06 2006, 01:15 PM
This disc is SWEET. Orange 175 flatter, in a head or tail I can pinpoint it >350 with a slight hyzer or slight annie. This disc will never leave my bag.
Compared to CFR, it is straighter (or maybe easier to throw straight)
Compared to Pro, it can take a bit more torque, and it's a little more overstable.
mikeP
Feb 15 2008, 10:30 AM
When I lost my original Star TL I couldn't find another of similar weight at the time and I ended up forgetting about it. Last weekend I came across another one and remembered why I threw it in the first place. Its a very sweet disc, sort of like a wind resistant XL/Leopard. I was just wondering how long it takes to get one broken in because I would like one that had some turn to its flight.
xterramatt
Feb 15 2008, 10:39 AM
Still got one in the bag. Probably need a new one, mine's getting flippy. Miss my original pink one. sniff.
rollinghedge
Feb 15 2008, 10:40 AM
These things are $$$.
xterramatt
Feb 15 2008, 10:52 AM
Most people don't give it a second look, but if they throw one, they are STAR<font color="red">TL</font>ed.
shaunh
Feb 15 2008, 11:25 AM
I got a nice 175 for eddie money shots and a 170 beater for annie who who's...
Great disc.
jmc2442
Feb 15 2008, 11:30 AM
Most people don't give it a second look, but if they throw one, they are STAR<font color="red">TL</font>ed.
:D
rromeo
Feb 15 2008, 12:45 PM
I have just bought a Red 170 Star TL and I am very suprised at how overstable it is. It is much more stable than my pro tl and more overstable than my Teebird. Infact it flies like a Teerex. What is up w/that? Did I get a freak disc?
boredatwork
Feb 15 2008, 01:48 PM
It will most likely soften up and work in to be extremely straight and predictable, sometimes the star come out very overstable at first but those are the best ones, they will last forever!
unicedmeman
Feb 15 2008, 01:55 PM
its possible that excess mold flashing is causing the disc to fly more overstable than intended
jimbob8
Feb 15 2008, 10:39 PM
Throw one in a straight, flatout head wind and watch it hold it's line right down the pipe. I love mine. Star TL is the sheet.