kkrasinski
Aug 18 2008, 02:04 PM
At Begg this past week the walking path in front of the basket on hole 17 was designated OB. A player's tee shot rolled onto the path and was curling back towards IB when a casual walker intentionally stepped on the disc causing the disc to stop OB. It is unclear whether or not the disc would have rolled IB.
A rule book was produced and 803.07(A) was read. No re-throw was taken.
The group and later a marshall ruled that since nobody could be sure that the unimpeded disc would have ended up OB, the disc should be spotted IB where it went out with no penalty.
Was the ruling correct, giving the benefit of the doubt to the player? Or was 803.07 circumvented?
A rule book was produced and 803.07(A) was read. No re-throw was taken.
The group and later a marshall ruled that since nobody could be sure that the unimpeded disc would have ended up OB, the disc should be spotted IB where it went out with no penalty.
Was the ruling correct, giving the benefit of the doubt to the player? Or was 803.07 circumvented?