Quote:
Originally Posted by DSproAVIAR
Chuck, this is false! Show me where I can read this in the rulebook. I'll repeat myself for the last time. There is only one requirement a disc needs to meet to be holed out-
"In order to
hole out, the thrower must release the disc
and it must come to rest supported by the
chains and/or the inner cylinder (bottom and
inside wall) of the tray."
Tell me how my disc did not "come to rest supported by the
chains and/or the inner cylinder (bottom and
inside wall) of the tray" and I will tell you that you are right and that the wording of this rule does not need to be changed.
|
Holy Christ, can you be more obtuse? You are completely ignoring the next line of the rule, which is also pretty important and is a condition of considering the disc holed out.
The rule specifically excludes all shots that enter the target in any way other than below the chain assembly and above the rim. Therefore, the only way a shot can enter the target and be considered holed out is below the chain assembly and above the rim. The exception being only if the disc's path is not witnessed, and in those cases the benefit of the doubt goes to the player and the disc is assumed to have passed over the rim and below the chain assembly (even if it is unlikely or impossible for the disc to have done so). And it's that exception that gives your shot any argument for being considered holed out at all here.