Originally Posted by cgkdisc
Not sure what the big issue is here. People come in all sizes and have different positions, stride and arm reach on every throw. Most stance rules essentially impact players differently based on their size and reach.
If we have a rule in which the application of said rule results in a different outcome for the exact same scenario dependent on the physical attributes of the player then I think there's something that could be improved with that rule.
Say you and Shaquille O'Neal throw the same shot that lands in exactly the same place, then through your interpretation, by rule
, you must play a more awkward lie while Shaq's big feet get him "relief" behind the solid obstacle. To me there's something wrong with that.
Appreciate the discourse Chuck. I'll pursue with the RC.