I figured you were right Kyle, and you are. You shot a 12 down but the scorecard is clearly marked a 44..
The front 9 line up with your names, but everyone dropped down a line on the back 9. Kind of strange.
I thought that might have caused the confusion but Johnny shot good on the front 9 but not as good on the back, so that wasn't it.
I counted the middle scores which were yours and it is a 12 down.